Geronimus
AT.
Black/white differences in the relationship of maternal age to birthweight:
a population-based test of the weathering hypothesis.
Soc Sci Med 1996;42(4):589-97.
African-American infants are at greater risk of being born preterm or
low birthweight than are white infants. Maternal age is conventionally
considered an important determinant of pregnancy outcome. The black/white
differential in infant mortality expands as maternal age increases. Also,
the proportion of adverse health and behavioral characteristics related
to poor pregnancy outcomes are greater among black women of reproductive
age than their white counterparts. The prevalence of these adverse factors
increases more rapidly among black women as they age than among white
women. Geronimus proposed the weathering hypothesis to explain this phenomenon.
The hypothesis posits that social and racial inequality may interact with
age to produce growing gaps in health among women of reproductive age
that may ultimately affect fetal health. The study explores whether specific
demographic and behavioral risk factors vary across African-American and
white populations and whether these risk factors contribute to black/white
disparity in birthweight. Black and white singleton first births to residents
of Michigan aged 15-34 (sample size=54888) were analyzed by linking birth
and death certificates. A validation study was conducted that showed that
economic characteristics of the areas remained stable over the past ten
years. Thus, appropriately the socioeconomic status of maternal residential
areas was derived from the 1980 census data.
For blacks, the rates of low birthweight and very low birthweight infants
increase as maternal age increases. For whites, the rates were lowest
among women in the 20s and greatest among the 15-19 and 30-34. The magnitude
of excess rate of low birthweight and very low birthweight among blacks
relative to whites increases with maternal age. The rates of smoking during
pregnancy among black women increase from their teen though their 30s,
while the rates decrease among the white women. The prevalence of smoking
is 4.5 times greater among white teens than black teens, but by ages 25-29
the prevalence is higher among the black women. The rates of hypertension
during pregnancy are higher among the older women, but the gradient is
steeper for the blacks than the whites. Within both whites and blacks,
younger mothers tend to live in more impoverished areas than the older
mothers. But, within each age category, blacks more often live in socioeconomically
disadvantaged areas than whites. For blacks, maternal age is statistically
related to low birthweight and very low birthweight, while maternal age
is not related to either outcome for whites. Among blacks residing in
impoverished areas, the odds of very low birthweight and the odds of low
birthweight respectively increase three-fold and four-fold between maternal
ages 15 and 34.
The rates of maternal health and behavioral characteristics, that may
adversely affect pregnancy outcome, tend to increase with age more rapidly
among African-American than white women living in urban areas in Michigan.
Maternal age represents both social processes as well as biological or
developmental process. Thus, whether older maternal age is a lower or
higher risk for adverse pregnancy outcome than younger maternal age depends
upon maternal race and socioeconomic status. Furthermore, maternal age
is an indicator of distinct health and behavioral attributes in different
populations. The study suggests that it may be inappropriate to apply
“routine clinical screening protocols that apply demographic risk
characteristics uniformly to estimate risk status in pregnancy.”
Previous thinking was that racial disparity in low and very birthweight
infants and infant mortality was reflective of the risk in the black teen
population. However, the findings indicate that the greatest decrease
in the racial disparity in birthweight and infant mortality should result
when clinical interventions are targeted to socioeconomically disadvantaged
primiparous black women in their 20s and 30s.